have both the old and the new and since I am "newer" to baby wearing I haven't tried much else. My first daughter hated all slings and carriers so we just gave up. Now that I have the ergos for Lily, they seem more exciting to Maya

I like the hood on the new Ergo better than the old one. The older version was not long enough for older children IMO. I am going to use them both to see if I like one better than the other and then I may sell off the unloved version. My husband just refuses to wear one!